The Complaint Shop
    All Your Complaints under one Roof
Tell the World
what went wrong
and hopefully the
world gets better
             
Last update
17/10/2007

Return to Index

Home

   Contacts

          
     
 
 
Complaint
Date
02/10/2003
 
 
Complaint
entered by
tonyd@aessdee.myinternetpass.com

 
 
Men's Shoes
Leather uppers and foot bed with PU soles
Ideal for Office wear
Sizes 7.5 to 10.5
Price per pair
                  г5.99
 

 


 
An advertisement placed by Lidl in the Daily Mirror on October 2nd for men's shoes stated that they were leather uppers and leather foot bed. In fact the uppers are plastic and they should be reported to trading standards office for misleading information. As these shoes were priced at only г5.99 it raised my suspicions and I drove a return trip of 20 miles to examine these myself and they were definitely plastic uppers.
 Can you contact them for an explanation?.
 

We faxed a copy of this e-mail  to Lidl asking them for their explanation and comment.
They came back quite promptly requesting contact details of Mr. Denby advising us that they would contact Mr. Denby  direct with the outcome of their investigation. We have asked them to provide us with a copy of their report and we have also asked Mr. Denby to let us know what Lidl have said in response to his complaint.

Mr. Denby has just sent us the following e-mail enclosing the reply from Lidl:
Sent: 17 October 2003
This is the reply I have now received. I cannot now prove anything, as I did not buy a pair.
But I ask you Leather Upper shoes for г5.99 . I wish. Thank you for your help. Next time I will get solid proof.
  Copy of the e-mail from Lidl
[received from Mr. Denby, not Lidl who regretfully ignored our request for a copy]
  Subject: Men's Shoes

 Dear Mr Denby
 
I am writing further to a complaint you have logged on The Complaint Shop website regarding Men's Shoes for  г 5.99 which were on sale in our stores  recently.
 
You were concerned that the shoes, which were advertised as Leather uppers and PU soles, were in fact plastic uppers. After fully investigating the matter with our suppliers and inspecting various samples of the shoes (all of which were Leather uppers as advertised), we have come to the conclusion that the shoes were in fact Leather uppers with PU soles as advertised and not Plastic uppers as indicated by you.
 
We are however more than happy to inspect the particular pair of shoes from which you have drawn your opinion. Please feel free to either send them directly to myself at the address below or hand them into one of our stores clearly stating that they have to be  sent to myself at the address below.
 
I hope that the above explanation proves to be satisfactory and would like to assure you of our best intentions at all times.
 

Yes Mr. Denby; you should have bought a pair to prove your complaint and substantiate your claim.
The low price is by no means an indication of inferior quality or of a wrong description.
 As it stands its game, set and match for Lidl.

 

Complaint Status:  closed Overall Efficiency:      
 Click To Download satisfactory  лллл
 
Respond Time    :      
 Click To Download satisfactory  лллл
 
Final Outcome    :      
     satisfactory  F Lidl
 
   
Further links to Lidl complaints:
Lidl Complaints  
Page up